# Children's Code assessment — ICO Age Appropriate Design Code **Service:** Diana Beauty School Plymouth (public site, portal, privacy notice) **Assessment date:** build v1.0 **Statutory basis:** Data Protection Act 2018 s.123; ICO Age Appropriate Design Code, in force 2 September 2021 **Status:** DRAFT — pending owner sign-off --- ## 1. Is the Code engaged? | Test | Answer | |---|---| | Is this an Information Society Service? | Yes — a website offering information and (from v1.1) services for payment | | Is it likely to be accessed by children in the UK? | **Yes, on a risk-based view.** The service is an adult academy and salon, but a child is realistically likely to reach the public pages: a parent researching a child's dry cut, or a 13–17 year old exploring a beauty career | | Child definition | Anyone under 18 (UNCRC; Code definition) | **Conclusion: the Code is engaged, and the standards below apply.** ## 2. Chosen compliance route The Code offers two routes for Standard 3 (age-appropriate application): 1. Establish age with a level of certainty proportionate to the risk; **or** 2. Apply the high-privacy standards to **all** users. **Decision taken: route 2 — apply the standards to everyone.** Reasoning: - The data involved is low-risk (name, phone, interest, preferred time). - The school's courses are 18+ by insurance and accreditation, so a hard age gate would be honest but would also mean collecting age data about every visitor to enforce a rule that only affects enrolment. - Route 2 avoids collecting age data at all, which is better data minimisation. - The ICO explicitly accepts route 2 as a valid approach. **Recorded assumption (required by the rule set):** "Children likely = yes; uniform high-privacy applied to all users." --- ## 3. The 15 standards — position for this build | # | Standard | Implementation | Status | |---|---|---|---| | 1 | **Best interests of the child** | No profiling, no ads, no location, no dark patterns; adult-only courses clearly labelled; safeguarding contacts published | Met | | 2 | **DPIA** | `DPIA.md` produced, covering risk by the five age bands | Met (draft, unsigned) | | 3 | **Age-appropriate application** | Route 2 — high privacy for all users; no age data collected | Met | | 4 | **Transparency** | `/privacy/` in plain English plus `getAgeAppropriatePrivacyNotice(ageBand)` for six bands, reachable from the top nav and the enquiry form | Met | | 5 | **Detrimental use** | No engagement optimisation, no content that could harm wellbeing, no data used against the child's interests | Met | | 6 | **Policies & community standards** | Portal enforces its own published rule (quiz pass mark before practical sessions unlock) in code | Met | | 7 | **Default settings** | Marketing unticked; profiling off; geolocation off; analytics absent; sharing denied by default. Locked and documented in portal Settings | Met | | 8 | **Data minimisation** | Five enquiry fields, no DOB, no address. Each field maps to a named purpose in the privacy table | Met | | 9 | **Data sharing** | No third parties receive data. Zero third-party network requests, verified by headless test. Booking remains in Versum/Booksy by the salon | Met | | 10 | **Geolocation** | Never requested. No `navigator.geolocation` in the codebase | Met | | 11 | **Parental controls** | None offered, so none to disclose. Parents book treatments for children directly with the salon | N/A | | 12 | **Profiling** | None. No recommendation engine, no behavioural scoring. The chat assistant (if added) produces offers deterministically from an explicit service table | Met | | 13 | **Nudge techniques** | Marketing unticked; no countdowns, no scarcity, no confirm-shaming; "Reset" and "Delete" confirm rather than coerce | Met | | 14 | **Connected toys/devices** | Not applicable to this service | N/A | | 15 | **Online tools** | Privacy page gives export, correction, deletion and complaint routes; a "Report a problem" section with 999, 0808 2000 247, Childline 0800 1111 and the ICO | Met | --- ## 4. Age-appropriate transparency — what is actually published The helper `getAgeAppropriatePrivacyNotice(ageBand)` in `assets/js/privacy.js` returns the same facts in six registers. Verified by test (`a11y.py` / `smoke.py`): | Band | Heading returned | Register | |---|---|---| | 0–5 | "A grown-up looks after this" | Third person, very short sentences | | 6–9 | "A grown-up does this part" | Third person, reassurance focused | | 10–12 | "Grown-ups use this site" | Explains what a business website is | | 13–15 | "What happens if you send an enquiry" | Addresses the reader, explains the 18+ rule plainly | | 16–17 | "Nearly an adult — same rules apply" | Peer register, explicit about rights | | 18+ | "The short version, for adults" | Full facts, lawful bases, retention | An unknown band falls back to the adult notice rather than guessing — verified (`getAgeAppropriatePrivacyNotice('bogus').band === '18+'`). Each band states the same collection, the same retention and the same rights. Only the language changes. This is a presentation layer over one policy, not six policies. --- ## 5. Children's data that will exist in v1.1 | Source | Data | Control | |---|---|---| | A 16–17 year old enquiring about a treatment | name, phone, interest, preferred time | Answered on their chosen route; no marketing unless opted in; deleted on schedule | | A parent booking a child's dry cut | child's name held by the **salon booking system**, not this website | Outside this system's scope; the salon remains responsible for that record | | A 16–17 year old applying for a course | name, phone, course interest | Declined with an 18+ explanation; not added to any list | **No child assessment, progress or quiz data is collected.** The portal is staff-and-student for adults only; under-18s are not enrolled. --- ## 6. Safeguarding The privacy page publishes: - **999** for immediate danger - **0808 2000 247** — National Domestic Abuse Helpline (free, 24h) - **0800 1111** — Childline - ICO complaint route (ico.org.uk, 0303 123 1113) If a conversational assistant is added in v1.1, the build prompt requires a safeguarding path that returns **zero offers**, no prices, the 0808 2000 247 number, and sets a safeguarding flag. This is a **gate**, not a nice-to-have: the assistant must not attempt to sell to a person disclosing abuse. --- ## 7. Gaps and actions | Gap | Risk | Action | Owner | Blocking | |---|---|---|---|---| | No signed DPIA | Medium | Owner reviews and signs `DPIA.md` | Owner | Yes | | No named privacy contact/DPO | Medium | Article 13 requires it; currently only a generic email | Owner | Yes | | Under-18 enquiries cannot be verified | Low–Medium | Accept: reply with the 18+ rule and do not market; revisit if enrolment policy changes | Owner | No | | No chat assistant yet | — | If added, implement the safeguarding path and deterministic mode first | Build | Yes (for v1.1) | | Age-appropriate notices not user-tested with real 13–17 year olds | Low | Comprehension check before launch | Owner | No | --- ## 8. Re-assessment triggers Re-run this assessment if any of the following changes: - A chat assistant or any AI surface is added - Any analytics, advertising or third-party script is introduced - Course eligibility drops below 18 - Any new data field is collected, especially date of birth or address - Payments are taken directly rather than through a hosted provider - Any data leaves the UK, or a new processor is engaged --- *This is an engineering assessment against the ICO Children's Code. It is not legal advice.*